The Difference between Man and Beast

Alyssa Ferguson
3 min readJun 9, 2023

A Comic Response

A few days ago my brother sent me an email with a link to the comic that appears below, asking, “What separates man from beasts? I want your take on this from a linguist’s point of view.” I had so much fun writing a response, I decided to share it here on Medium. It appears below the comic.

Image by existentialcomics.com. Used by permission.

I am glad you asked me this question, because it is one I think about from time to time. But the question begs a larger one that logically comes first, namely, whether there is indeed a categorical difference between man and beast; or, to put it another way, whether the difference between man and beast is more like the difference between a fish and a bird, or between a fish and a rock. Or again: is the difference one of kind, or merely of degree? Or again: is there any reason to suppose, a priori, that there is some quality shared by all men (for with such a term is the question framed) that is categorically absent in beasts?

I think it is safe to say that, throughout the course of human history, the great majority of the people who have considered the question in something like this last formulation, and committed their thought to writing that has survived the ravages of time to come down to us, have assumed an affirmative as obvious or even self-evident, and have quickly moved on to the later question of what that…

--

--

Alyssa Ferguson
Alyssa Ferguson

Written by Alyssa Ferguson

Born and raised in a literary household, I write to clarify my own questions.

No responses yet